Australasia & Pacific
A Means and Measure of Civilisation: Colonial Authorities and Indigenous Law in Australasia
By , University College Oxford (November 2003)
Sections: Australasia & Pacific
Subjects: Law, Imperial, Colonial, and Postcolonial History, History, Colonial History.
Places: Oceania, Australasia.
Periods: 1000 - 1999, 1800-1899.
Abstract
British commentators on colonial policy in the early to mid-nineteenth century often treated the existence of indigenous customary law and adjudicative forums as an indication of ‘civilisation’. However, not all customary laws were considered ‘civilised’ enough to be acknowledged by the British authorities. Furthermore, most British policy and debate was assimilationist. This article surveys two different assimilationist approaches. ‘Exceptionalist’ proposals favoured modifying the application of English law to indigenous peoples as a preliminary step towards assimilation. Such schemes can be contrasted with proposals for the ‘strict application’ of English law over indigenous peoples. In practice, however, the distinction between the two approaches was often blurred. Commentators and officials treated law as a means and measure of civilisation. The tension between these two roles often contributed to confused and ambiguous discussions of the application of English law to indigenous peoples. This article, therefore, suggests that Henry Reynolds’ views on British attitudes to indigenous customary law are overstated. The article concludes with a brief discussion of the distinction between legal and historical reasoning, and the limited implications of my historical arguments for the legal reasoning of cases such as Mabo and Wik.
DOI: 10.1111/1478-0542.049
This article abstract has been viewed 8717 times.
Top 5 related articles
-
The Native Police of Queensland
By , Griffith University, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
(Vol. 6, May 2008)
History Compass -
Voyages, Encounters, and Agency in Oceania: Captain Cook and Indigenous People
By , Australian National University
(Vol. 6, May 2008)
History Compass -
Ngāi Tahu Historiography
By , University of Otago, New Zealand
(Vol. 5, April 2007)
History Compass -
Genocide and Holocaust Consciousness in Australia
By , Department of History, University of Sydney, Australia
(Vol. 1, August 2003)
History Compass -
A Feather Bed Dictionary: Colonialism and Sexuality
By , Centre of Public Culture and Ideas, Griffith University
(Vol. 5, May 2007)
History Compass
Top 5 Related Blackwell Reference Chapters
Samkange, Sketchley Siyangapi (1936–1961)
Born in 1936 into a deeply Christian and politically active family in Southern Rhodesia, Sketchley Samkange ...
By Catherine Cymone Fourshey
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest
Nujoma, Sam (b. 1929)
Sam Daniel Shafiishuna Nujoma was born on May 12, 1929 at Etunda in Ongandjera district in the north ...
By Tilman Dedering
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest
African Blood Brotherhood
W. E. B. Du Bois's Darkwater (1920) and Lothrop Stoddard's Rising Tide of Color Against White World-Supremacy ...
By Roderick Bush
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest
Malawi national liberation
Historically, Malawi's population was centered in the fertile southern highlands and a thin belt along ...
By Eliakim Sibanda
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest
Malaysia, protest and revolt
Malaysia is a multicultural society that was born in the throes of protest, largely influenced by British ...
By Collin Rajasingham Abraham
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest