Middle & Near East
Grieving Cosmopolitanism in Middle East Studies
By , McGill University (September 2008)
Section: Middle & Near East
Subjects: History Writing, Nations and Peoples, Imperial, Colonial, and Postcolonial History, Social History, Study of History, History, Urban History.
Places: World, Mediterranean.
Key Topics: identity, social class.
Abstract
Political philosophers and cultural theorists studying twenty-first-century globalization have found cosmopolitanism to be a productive concept. In Middle East scholarship, however, cosmopolitan has been less than effective. This review illustrates three characteristics of cosmopolitanism in Middle East historiography – elitism in formulation and content, grieving nostalgia, and the privileging of formal labels over content – with examples from nineteenth-century cities and globalized metropolises. Scholars must confront the anti-nationalist teleology and secularizing, bourgeois fantasy at the heart of cosmopolitanism as it is currently used if they are to produced more accurate accounts of diversity in Middle East societies past and present.
DOI: 10.1111/j.1478-0542.2008.00545.x
This article abstract has been viewed 3437 times.
Top 5 related articles
-
The Historiography of Sectarianism in Lebanon
By , Harvard Society of Fellows
(Vol. 6, December 2008)
History Compass -
Ottoman Judicial Change in the Age of Modernity: A Reappraisal
By , Ben-Gurion University
(Vol. 6, November 2008)
History Compass -
Modern Education in Iran during the Qajar and Pahlavi Periods
By , University of Texas at Austin
(Vol. 6, November 2008)
History Compass -
Modern Syrian Politics
By , University of St. Andrews
(Vol. 5, November 2007)
History Compass -
Searching History: The Non-Elite in Ancient Egypt
By , University of Michigan
(Vol. 5, March 2007)
History Compass
Top 5 Related Blackwell Reference Chapters
Social Structure and Demography
In the fourth of his orations against Catiline, delivered before the Senate in 63, Cicero asserts once ...
By Neville Morley
Palmares slave revolts, 1602–1603
Palmares was a quilombo (in English, a “maroon society”) or settlement founded by runaway slaves in Pernambuco, ...
By Gregory R. Smulewicz-Zucker
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest
Mapuche Indian resistance
The process of integration of Mapuche territories to the administration of the Chilean state was known ...
By Héctor Guerra Hernández and Raúl Ortíz Contreras
From The International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest
The Construction of the Past in the Roman Empire
More than any men known to us, the Romans love their city and strive to protect all their ancestral treasures ...
By Rowland Smith
Identity, Ethnicity, and “Race”
The assertiveness of indigenous and Afro-Latin peoples in Latin America has a long history. Rebellions, ...
By Peter Wade